· Preseason

Preseason Report #3: He Has Now Played The Exact Same Season Twice

Jakobi Wan Kenobi owns the single most valuable player in this league and has finished 7-7 two years running — winning the same playoff game, losing to the same team, then losing the same consolation game. Twice. Identically.

Report #3. Some franchises are hard to summarize. Jakobi Wan Kenobi is not one of them, because he has helpfully run the experiment twice and gotten the same answer both times.

The Résumé

Read these two rows carefully. They are not a typo.

2024 2025
Record 7-7 7-7
Round 1 Won vs The Death Star Won vs Darth Maulvin Jr.
Round 2 Lost to Amon Ra dawg Padme Lost to Amon Ra dawg Padme
Third-place game Lost to Chase Windu Lost to Chase Windu

Two seasons. Same record. Won his first-round game both times. Ran into Amon Ra dawg Padme in the second round both times and lost both times. Fell into the third-place game both times and lost that to Chase Windu — both times.

Four rounds of playoff football across two years, and the bracket has produced the identical sentence twice: good enough to win a game, not good enough to beat the champion, then not good enough to salvage third.

There is no version of this that is bad luck. Bad luck is random. This is a result.

The Good

He owns the best player in Grogu's Gridiron. Not a good player. The player.

Jahmyr Gibbs is worth 11,359 on the dynasty market — the highest-valued asset in this entire league, ahead of Bijan Robinson (11,241) on The Death Star. He is 24 years old. Nobody in this league has a better single piece, and it isn't especially close to being a debate.

Behind Gibbs the young talent is real. Tetairoa McMillan, 23, at 4,577. Carnell Tate, 21, at 4,366 — taken 1.02 in the rookie draft with a first-round pick he acquired from Yoda Cock. Caleb Williams, 24, at quarterback. Kenneth Walker, 25, worth 4,705 and playing the same position as the best player in the league, which is a nice problem.

And the Tate pick deserves specific credit. He sent Bucky Irving (3,451 today) and Juwan Johnson (1,200) to Yoda Cock for that 2026 first and a 2028 fourth. It came back as a 21-year-old receiver worth 4,366. That's a clean piece of business — he sold a 23-year-old back into a market that wanted one and turned it into someone two years younger and worth more.

The Bad

Here is the problem with owning the best player in the league.

Jakobi Wan Kenobi ranks 8th of 10 in total player value, at 54,706.

Eighth. With the number one asset in the league on his roster. Gibbs alone accounts for 20.8% of this team's entire player value — more than a fifth of everything he owns, standing in one pair of shoes. Take Gibbs off this roster and what remains is not a contender's supporting cast; it's the thinnest collection of complementary parts among the top eight teams.

That's what two identical 7-7 seasons actually look like from the inside. The top of the roster is championship quality. The middle is not, and the middle is what decides fourteen regular-season games.

He also did essentially nothing about it this offseason. One trade all year — the Yoda Cock deal in June, which was good — and then three waiver claims in late July totaling five dollars. Two dollars on Mike Gesicki. Two dollars on Noah Gray. One dollar on Carson Beck. That's the entire offseason for a team that has now lost the same playoff game to the same opponent two years running.

Doing the same thing and expecting a different result is a whole saying. Someone should tell him.

The Ugly

Let's talk about the five dollars.

The starting lineup in this league is one quarterback and one tight end. Jakobi Wan Kenobi rosters five quarterbacks and five tight ends.

QBs: Caleb Williams, Trevor Lawrence, Carson Beck, Mac Jones, Jameis Winston. TEs: Eli Stowers, Travis Kelce, David Njoku, Mike Gesicki, Noah Gray.

Ten roster spots — better than a third of his twenty-eight — devoted to two positions that start one player each on Sunday. He can field a quarterback and a tight end and still have eight of them watching from the couch. And in the last week of July, with that already true, he went to the waiver wire and added two more of them.

The tight end room averages 29.2 years old and is anchored by a 36-year-old Travis Kelce — the oldest non-quarterback in this entire league, and by a distance. The next-oldest player who isn't a QB is Davante Adams at 33.

Which brings us to the thing everyone says about this franchise: that it's an old receiving corps running on borrowed time. Half right. His pass catchers as a group average 27.0 years old — the oldest in the league, yes. But that number is almost entirely the tight ends. His actual wide receivers average 25.9, and the two best of them are 23 and 21 years old. The wideouts are fine. It's the five tight ends dragging the average into assisted living.

On The Record

He owns the most valuable player in this league, and seven teams still have more talent than he does. He has played the identical season twice — same record, same first-round win, same elimination by the same team, same loss in the same consolation game. And he answered it with one trade and five dollars.

The prediction: Jakobi Wan Kenobi makes the playoffs and does not reach the final. A third consecutive trip that ends before the last game. The talent at the top gets him in; the middle of this roster is why he doesn't finish. If he wants a different December, the roster needed a different August.


Next up, Thursday, August 20: THE EMPIRE STRIKES BACK, who reached the final in 2024 and then went 2-12. Nobody in this league has fallen further, faster.

The Holocron will be watching.


How was this dispatch?

Help H0-L0 improve the next one.

← Back to all dispatches